Week 13: Paper Editing Workshop

Full paper peer review. Bring your complete paper draft. Today you will swap papers with a classmate from a different team, read and annotate their full paper, and then deliver structured feedback in two rounds. Every reviewer has a new assignment from the first workshop.

Schedule

Time Phase What to Do
2:50–3:15 Silent Reading Read your assigned paper carefully. Annotate with pen: = clear, ? = confused, = compelling.
3:15–3:35 Round 1: Feedback to Teams M, P, S Reviewers assigned to Teams M, P, and S sit with those teams and deliver feedback. Teams B, E, J: use this time to discuss your paper among yourselves.
3:35–3:55 Round 2: Feedback to Teams B, E, J Reviewers assigned to Teams B, E, and J sit with those teams and deliver feedback.
3:55–4:10 Writing Sprint Back with your own team. Each person claims one issue to revise and starts editing.
4:10–4:20 Wrap-up Final paper assignments for next week.

Reading Assignments

Find your name below to see which paper you are reading and annotating during silent reading (2:50–3:15). Everyone reads the introduction (pp 1–2). Your focus pages are the additional pages you are responsible for reviewing in detail.

ReviewerReviewingFocus PagesHome Team
Ananya MalikTeam Jpp 1–5Team M
Armita KazeminajafabadiTeam Bpp 1–4Team P
Arya WuTeam Ppp 1–4Team J
Avery HuangTeam Ppp 1–2, 5–6Team B
Ayush AgrawalTeam Bpp 1–2, 5–6Team S
Christopher CurtisTeam Jpp 1–2, 6–7Team P
Claire SchlesingerTeam Ppp 1–2, 7–8Team E
Courtney MaynardTeam Mpp 1–4Team B
Emre TapanTeam Spp 1–4Team B
Grace ProebstingTeam Mpp 1–2, 5–6Team B
Guangyuan WengTeam Bpp 1–2, 7–8Team M
Haoyu HeTeam Bpp 1–2, 8–9Team S
Isaac DalkeTeam Epp 1–4Team P
Jasmine CuiTeam Spp 1–2, 5–6Team J
Jesseba FernandoTeam Mpp 1–2, 7–8Team J
Kai NylundTeam Epp 1–2, 5–6Team P
Keivalya PandyaTeam Epp 1–2, 7–8Team M
Luze SunTeam Spp 1–2, 7–8Team E
Rice WangTeam Mpp 1–2, 8–9Team E
Shuyi LinTeam Ppp 1–2, 8–9Team E
Yiqian LiTeam Jpp 1–2, 8–9Team S
Yuchen HouTeam Spp 1–2, 8–9Team J
Yuqi PengTeam Epp 1–2, 8–9Team S

Round 1 Discussion (3:15–3:35): Feedback to Teams M, P, S

Teams B, E, J: use this time to discuss your own paper among yourselves.

Team M — Maps / Navigation

Receiving: Ananya Malik, Keivalya Pandya, Guangyuan Weng, Germans Savcisens, Natalie Shapira

Reviewers: Grace Proebsting (B), Courtney Maynard (B), Rice Wang (E), Jesseba Fernando (J)

Team P — Power

Receiving: Christopher Curtis, Armita Kazeminajafabadi, Isaac Dalke, Kai Nylund

Reviewers: Avery Huang (B), Claire Schlesinger (E), Shuyi Lin (E), Arya Wu (J)

Team S — Spatial / VLM

Receiving: Yuqi Peng, Haoyu He, Ayush Agrawal, Yiqian Li

Reviewers: Emre Tapan (B), Luze Sun (E), Yuchen Hou (J), Jasmine Cui (J)

Round 2 Discussion (3:35–3:55): Feedback to Teams B, E, J

Team B — Political Bias

Receiving: Avery Huang, Grace Proebsting, Emre Tapan, Courtney Maynard, Gabriele Sarti, David Atkinson

Reviewers: Guangyuan Weng (M), Armita Kazeminajafabadi (P), Haoyu He (S), Ayush Agrawal (S)

Team E — Economics

Receiving: Claire Schlesinger, Luze Sun, Rice Wang, Shuyi Lin, Veronica Perez

Reviewers: Keivalya Pandya (M), Isaac Dalke (P), Kai Nylund (P), Yuqi Peng (S)

Team J — Journalism / Roles

Receiving: Jasmine Cui, Jesseba Fernando, Yuchen Hou, Arya Wu, Peter Li, Sophie Wang

Reviewers: Ananya Malik (M), Christopher Curtis (P), Yiqian Li (S)

Tips for Giving Good Feedback on Full Papers